I like the Ford Escape Hybrid. It is the best value out of the three. Rather than uninformed opinions like most other posters are giving you, here are some cold hard facts:
The FEH uses a planetary-gear Power Split Device (PSD) transmission that is very similar to the Toyota Hybrid Synergy Drive (HSD) used in the Highlander Hybrid, so it has all of the same low-maintenance benefits as the HiHy, but the FEH costs a lot less.
Benefits of a PSD/HSD-equipped car:
- Uses regenerative braking, which means you don't need to change the brake pads until after 100,000 miles. (Regular cars like the Honda CR-V will need a brake job every 30,000 miles or so).
- Transmission reliability. The PSD/HSD transmission is just one single gearset, no gear-shifting, no clutches. Its simplicity means it's a lot tougher than regular gear-shifting multispeed transmissions (such as the one in the CR-V), or belt-driven CVT trannies.
- No starter solenoid / motor (which frequently causes trouble in regular cars-- "boo hoo hoo, my car won't start!"), no alternator, no timing belt. Less things to wear out.
The Ford PSD system and the Toyota HSD both have 8-year warranties, so if the traction battery dies within 8 years, they will replace it for free.
Not to mention the great gas mileage of the PSD/HSD-equipped vehicles, which is almost an afterthought.
As far as I'm concerned, you really can't go wrong with a PSD/HSD-equipped vehicle, which includes:
- All Toyota hybrids (Hybrid Synergy Drive)
- All Lexus hybrids (Hybrid Synergy Drive)
- Ford Escape Hybrid (own-developed PSD drive)
- Nissan Altima Hybrid (licensed Toyota Hybrid Synergy Drive)
But as far as hybrid SUVs are concerned, I feel the FEH is the best value.