What should I pay for a used 95 Subaru Outback with 128k miles in good condition?

[Brian C]

95 Outback128k mi asking price: 3750
For sale by individual
KBB.com (Kelly Blue Book) values:
FairGoodExcellent
Retail5680
Private 335038904340
Trade 203526753050
note: car was driven in the chicago/wisconsin area as a commuter car so exposed to winter conditions since 95